cases, commentary and news related to restrictive covenants
Friday, November 13, 2009
Temporary Restraining Order In Non-Compete Case Requires Showing of Immediate Harm (Ride-Away Handicap Equip. v. Tracey)
Employer seeking immediate redress from threatened competitive harm have to move fast. The preferred remedy in most non-compete disputes is an injunction, and for extreme emergencies, an employer can seek a temporary restraining order - in effect, a paper trial before the court hears live evidence.
TROs are important because the employer will be largely in control of the documents. At a preliminary injunction, the defense has the benefit of time - time to amass evidence, prepare witnesses and find helpful third-party testimony.
But TROs require exigency. Illustrating this key point is a decision from earlier in the week in Florida federal court. In Ride-Away Handicap Equipment v. Tracey, the employer waited four months after sending a "cease and desist" letter to two ex-employees (and its new employer) to file a TRO petition. It also appears the employer gave no notice of the TRO to the defendants. Notice is not required in some circumstances, but the moving party must show why irreparable injury would result from lack of notice.
The court was unimpressed with the employer's delay and denied the TRO petition without a response. There is no bright-line rule for when an employer must move for injunctive relief. Immediacy, in fact, can arise during the pendency of a dispute, for example if an ex-employee suddenly starts poaching other co-workers or discloses confidential information to a customer in violation of a contract. But in a case where the breach is known to the employer, and the employer waits a few months to seek an injunction to stop that breach, it risks losing a valuable equitable right.
Court: United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida
Opinion Date: 11/10/09
Cite: Ride-Away Handicap Equipment Corp. v. Tracey, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 104984 (M.D. Fla. 2009)
Law: Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Post a Comment